We'll cut to the chase
You'll love our newsletter.
SIGN ME UP

Follow The Tempest

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • YouTube
  • Email

Discover

  • Life

    Uncensored reality. For everyone.

  • Love

    Relationships, redefined.

  • News

    News for a new world order.

  • Now + Beyond

    Innovation powered by you.

  • Weddings

    Unapologetically celebrating love.

  • Social Justice

    Our revolution. Our world.

  • Pop Culture

    Entertainment that breaks barriers.

  • Lookbook

    Serving fresh looks by you, for you.

Skip to content
  • Explore
  • Latest

The Tempest INC

  • Emails

    Our emails are made to shine in your inbox, with something fresh every morning, afternoon, and weekend.

    • The Tempest Weekly

      Everything you’ll want to know about living your best life, curated for you by our very own founder.

    • The Tempest Need/Want/Love

      A selection of today’s best stories to keep you in the know

  • Get early access
In partnership with AT&T
Weddings

Proposing in public is awful – here’s why you should never do it

Almost nobody wants this.

By Jordan Moldenhauer September 14, 2019
The Tempest
[Image description: Man seems sad after a proposal while a woman walks away.] via Youtube
[Image description: Man seems sad after a proposal while a woman walks away.] via Youtube
[Image description: Man seems sad after a proposal while a woman walks away.] via Youtube

Make waves in your inbox

Join us
87
ShareTweet

At the 2016 Rio Olympics, Chinese diver He Zi took home the silver.

Following years of training and fierce competition, she was dubbed second best in the world in the three-meter springboard dive. After stepping down from the podium though, she found fellow Olympic athlete and long-time boyfriend, Qin Ka, down on one knee, proposing.

Imagine being upstaged by your significant other during a defining moment of your career.

That is a day He Zi will forever look back on and see, not only her crowning achievement but the day that her boyfriend proposed. If might just be me, but I think those things could easily have been on two separate days.

Don’t get me wrong, it was a sweet moment (she said yes, for one). For years, though, the word on public engagements has been a resounding “no” with feminist writers detecting hints of manipulation in what should be a sweet and significant moment for the couple. 

But the brides have had their say too. According to David’s Bridal’s “What’s On Brides’ Minds” survey, brides overwhelmingly prefer a more personal, private proposal. 80% said they would scoff at a public Facebook proposal, 63% would not want to be proposed to on a jumbotron, and 57% of the respondents would not want to be proposed to via flashmob. 

And with good reasons.

Number one is public pressure.

Imagine being surprise proposed to by your significant other in front of a crowd of strangers. Your response has to be “yes” because if it isn’t, the whole situation will be awkward. The public pressure, then, is definitely manipulative because if you wanted to say no to the engagement, you risk embarrassing yourself and your partner, as well as hurting your partner’s feelings.

There is enough pressure in a private setting without doing that in front of other people.

Another key reason brides tend to stray away from public proposals is the stage fright. She won’t be able to savor the moment if she feels like she’s on stage, even if she wants to say yes. 

“I think the biggest thing you can do to help a marriage is to have absolute privacy [for the proposal],” said Calgary-based marriage conflict specialist, Debra Macleod. Macleod has had clients whose marriage began with a showy proposal only to have one of the partners be quietly resentful that their “private moment” had been transformed into a public spectacle.

So, if the evidence clearly states that public proposals are a no-go, why do people continue to propose in that way?

Take Bharat and Romi, a beautiful couple that was engaged recently. By the end of Bharat’s flashmob engagement at the Leicester Square Christmas Festival, the pair looked extraordinarily happy. Romi was definitely surprised but seemed genuinely happy as well.

If you remove everything I previously stated – the pressure, the stage fright, the manipulation – this engagement was perfect. It feels like a romantic movie moment from the 1980s where the woman had no doubts that this is who she wanted to be with and had no worries about being in front of a crowd. 

The main issue with public proposals, though, is consent.

Yes, I get it. It is meant as a romantic gesture but too many proposals are complete surprises to the significant others, and too many of those proposals are done in front of crowds of friends, family, or strangers.

As one Redditor points out, a general rule of thumb is that the proposal itself should not be a surprise. The couple should have a discussion about marriage and if that is the direction they’d like to go in, the creativity can start from there, based on your partner’s interests.

If Romi was interested in romantic gestures then, Bharat did an amazing job.

Engagements are beautiful. It’s a moment that is meant to signify the rest of your lives. It’s for the couple – however the couple wants to express it.

But if you’re going to propose in public, be sure your fiance-to-be will be comfortable with it.


https://thetempest.co/?p=119715
Jordan Moldenhauer

By Jordan Moldenhauer

Editorial Fellow

 Follow         Follow
Tags
feminism , wedding , health , Sex , LGBTQ , entertainment , social justice , The Tempest , bride , groom , police brutality , climate change , body positivity , dating , The Tempest fellowships , The Tempest Media , write for the tempest , engagement , space , arts , thetempest.co , celebrity , The Tempest podcast , consent , innovation , mashal waqar the tempest , fashion tips , significant other , proposal , engaged , Laila Alawa The Tempest , the tempest characters , the tempest media company , The Tempest Team , the tempest founder , Laila Alawa Interview , wedding proposal , Laila Alawa Forbes , The Tempest Careers , The Tempest sparknotes , the tempest summary , the tempest pdf , the tempest king , the tempest quotes , the tempest movie , the tempest translation , the tempest caliban , the tempest shmoop , the tempest media inc , the tempest facebook , the tempest jobs , the tempest pitch , tempest site , the tempest common sense media , the tempest shakespeare summary , the tempest shakespeare pdf , the tempest shakespeare movie , the tempest summary act 1 , the tempest summary act 2 , the tempest summary shmoop , the tempest inc , the tempest summary act 1 scene 2 , the tempest summary act 3 , the tempest summary act 4 , the tempest summary video , the tempest summary youtube , the tempest summary pdf , the tempest summary act 3 scene 3 , the tempest summary and analysis , the tempest company utah , the tempest shakespeare company , the tempest brewing company , the tempest trading company , the tempest royal shakespeare company , the tempest royal shakespeare company reviews , the tempest shakespeare theatre company , the tempest royal shakespeare company dvd , the tempest royal shakespeare company cast , the tempest shakespeare and company , the tempest royal shakespeare company 2016 , laila alawa net worth , laila alawa wikipedia , laila alawa instagram , laila alawa facebook , laila alawa huffington post , laila alawa wiki , mashal waqar instagram , laila alawa twitter , modern woman's destination , how to live a stylish well-rounded life , breaking entertainment news , feminist media studies , feminist media histories , feminist media outlets , feminist websites , feminist websites india , feminist websites australia , feminist websites uk , feminist website babe , feminist website jezebel , feminist websites canada , feminist websites america , feminist website blog , radical feminist websites , the tempest 40 women to watch , best feminist websites 2018 , feminist website uk , feminist clothing website , feminist comedy website , best website for women's accessories , the best women's clothing websites , top women's media outlets , top female media executives , thetempest co , laila alawa wedding , laila alawa podcast , laila alawa youtube , mashal waqar net worth , mashal waqar birthday , laila alawa blog , mashal waqar twitter , laila alawa birthday , laila alawa the expose , laila alawa cnn , where is mashal waqar from , tech entrepreneur laila alawa , where is laila alawa from , laila alawa husband , laila alawa nationality , mashal waqar nationality , laila alawa quotes , laila alawa images , the tempest media wikipedia , mashal waqar wikipedia , mashal waqar images , mashal waqar quotes , laila alawa books , mashal waqar interview , the tempest media podcast , the tempest shop , the tempest house , the tempest networking , the tempest book , the tempest media gifts , the tempest apps , the tempest accessories , the tempest apparel , the tempest affirmations , the tempest foundation , the tempest gifts , the tempest art , the tempest online , the tempest blogs , the tempest clothing , the tempest coffee mug , the tempest woman , the tempest collective , the tempest events , the tempest empire , the tempest earrings , Farwa Farshori The Tempest , farwa farshori research , farwa farshori academics , farwa farshori growth hacking , farwa farshori entrepreneur , farwa farshori chief growth officer , farwa farshori media , farwa farshori where is she from , farwa farshori wikipedia , farwa farshori nationality , farwa farshori interview , farwa farshori birthday , david's bridal , ahlam abdelkader media , ahlam abdelkader where is she from , ahlam abdelkader wikipedia , ahlam abdelkader nationality , ahlam abdelkader the tempest , ahlam abdelkader video , ahlam abdelkader interview , ahlam abdelkader birthday , Jordan Moldenhauer The Tempest , public proposal , public engagement , private proposal , finace , 2016 Rio Olympics , He Zi , Qin Ka , Leicester Square Christmas Festival , marriage consent , relationship consent , public proposals gone wrong , public proposals are the worst , public proposals manipulative , public proposals rejected , public proposals are bad , public proposals gone bad , public proposals bad idea , failed public proposals , public proposals are manipulative , best public proposals , cute public proposals , crazy public proposals , embarrassing public proposals , The Tempest Studio ,
READ THIS NEXT Lookbook
Shopping, Makeup, Under $50, Style & Beauty, Beauty, Amazon, Beauty, Lookbook
[Image description: A woman's lips are visible, wearing a perfect nude lipstick. Next to her, a matte nude lipstick.] via Unsplash [Image description: A woman's lips are visible, wearing a perfect nude lipstick. Next to her, a matte nude lipstick.] via Unsplash

10 nude lipstick shades that look absolutely perfect on brown skin tones
Zathia Bazeer

We'll cut to the chase
You'll love our newsletter.
SIGN ME UP

MOST TALKED ABOUT

Editor’s Pick of the Day

[Image description: Netflix's latest mother-daughter duo Ginny and Georgia seated in a car.] Via Netflix
TV ShowsLookbook
Don't be fooled, 'Ginny and Georgia' is no 'Gilmore Girls'
Maheen Humayun
March 3, 2021
Grayscale photo of woman lying on a bed sleeping
MindLookbook
Do you suddenly jerk or twitch in your sleep? If so, here's why!
Rebecca Azad
February 23, 2021
[Image description: Simone Ashley playing Olivia in 'Sex Education' looking to the side and wearing a red jacket. ] Via Netflix
TV ShowsLookbook
Bridgerton's new leading lady Kate Sharma is here- and she's South Asian!
Mishma Nixon
February 15, 2021

UP NEXT

[Image description: Promo poster for the television series "WandaVision."] Via queenscitizen.ca
[Image description: Promo poster for the television series "WandaVision."] Via queenscitizen.ca

Pop Culture

What “WandaVision” gets right about navigating grief
What “WandaVision” gets right about navigating grief
Ebony Purks
March 5, 2021
[Image description: Collage of celebrities and events related to American pop culture.] Via eonline.com
[Image description: Collage of celebrities and events related to American pop culture.] Via eonline.com

I used to resist pop culture. Here’s why I’m changing my mind
I used to resist pop culture. Here’s…
Tamia Adolph
March 5, 2021
[Image description: A scene from 'Modern Love' where Anne Hathaway is seen walking the store aisle dressed in evening clothes] via Amazon Prime Video
[Image description: A scene from 'Modern Love' where Anne Hathaway is seen walking the store aisle dressed in evening clothes] via Amazon Prime Video

Pop Culture

‘Modern Love’ shows that the love pill does not fix everything
‘Modern Love’ shows that the love pill…
Haddiqua Siddiqui
March 4, 2021
[Image description: Netflix's latest mother-daughter duo Ginny and Georgia seated in a car.] Via Netflix
[Image description: Netflix's latest mother-daughter duo Ginny and Georgia seated in a car.] Via Netflix

TV Shows

Don’t be fooled, ‘Ginny and Georgia’ is no ‘Gilmore Girls’
Don’t be fooled, ‘Ginny and Georgia’ is…
Maheen Humayun
March 3, 2021
Portrait of Fatima Al-Fihri
Portrait of Fatima Al-Fihri

Forgotten History

Fatima al-Fihri: Founder of the world’s first university
Fatima al-Fihri: Founder of the world’s first…
Rebecca Azad
March 3, 2021

Life

Are influencers actually a bad influence on us?
Are influencers actually a bad influence on…
Safa Shoaib
March 2, 2021
[Image description: An illustration closeup of a woman holding her hand up to her lips.] Illustration by Maheen Humayun
[Image description: An illustration closeup of a woman holding her hand up to her lips.] Illustration by Maheen Humayun

Health

Big boobs are a HASSLE! Let’s talk about it
Big boobs are a HASSLE! Let’s talk…
Rebecca Azad
March 2, 2021
Sunglasses sitting on folded white shirt with a tag that says 'sustainable', on top of terrazzo side table
Sunglasses sitting on folded white shirt with a tag that says 'sustainable', on top of terrazzo side table

Style

Here are 8 tips on building a sustainable wardrobe without breaking the bank
Here are 8 tips on building a…
Rebecca Azad
March 1, 2021

Books

26 most anticipated book releases for March 2021
26 most anticipated book releases for March…
Talia Basma
March 1, 2021

Historical Badasses

Elizabeth Catlett’s art reminds us to keep fighting
Elizabeth Catlett’s art reminds us to keep…
Jessica Land
February 28, 2021
A woman with her child walking along a dock.
A woman with her child walking along a dock.

Gender & Identity

I don’t want children and there’s nothing wrong with that
I don’t want children and there’s nothing…
Natalia Ahmed
February 26, 2021
A woman dressed in Igbo traditional dress, surrounded by friends and family.
A woman dressed in Igbo traditional dress, surrounded by friends and family.

Here are wedding traditions from 12 African countries you need to know
Here are wedding traditions from 12 African…
Danai Nesta Kupemba
February 26, 2021

Now + Beyond

Music streaming platforms are changing the music industry in more ways than you know
Music streaming platforms are changing the music…
Tatayana Allen
February 24, 2021
Featured Video Play Icon 0
Videos Audio + Visual

14 MORE Startup Stereotypes All Founders Hate

TempestVideo January 15, 2020

Trending Videos

Featured Video Play Icon
Videos
14 MORE Startup Stereotypes All Founders Hate
TempestVideo
January 15, 2020
Featured Video Play Icon
Videos
Beauty Stereotypes We're Tired of Hearing About
TempestVideo
December 15, 2019
Featured Video Play Icon
Videos
Yerba Mate: The Intelligent Alternative To Coffee
TempestVideo
February 23, 2019
Featured Video Play Icon
Videos
7 times we proved how good the world actually is
The Tempest Studio
February 21, 2018
-->
Discover
The Tempest Stories, Obsessions & News
Watch
The Tempest Original Series & Shorts
Subscribe
THE TEMPEST EMAILS

© 2021 THE TEMPEST INC.

Company

  • About Us
  • Our Lists
  • Shop
  • Careers
  • Write for Us
  • Become a Member
  • Press
  • Feedback

Information

  • The Tempest News
  • Terms
  • Privacy
  • Archives
  • Advertising
  • RSS

COME HERE OFTEN?

Get MORE of The Tempest!

© 2021 THE TEMPEST INC.

Company

  • About Us
  • Our Lists
  • Shop
  • Careers
  • Write for Us
  • Become a Member
  • Press
  • Feedback

Information

  • The Tempest News
  • Terms
  • Privacy
  • Archives
  • Advertising
  • RSS

COME HERE OFTEN?

Get MORE of The Tempest!