Culture, Gender & Identity, Life

7 questions I get when people try to figure out where I’m from.

I was just white to this stranger I had just met. This stranger suddenly knew I was white. I didn’t even know who I was.

1. “Where are you from, sister?”


This is probably an innocent question, but I don’t know when I’ve ever viewed it with anything less than stress and trepidation.

When around someone I’ve just had the pleasure of meeting, the question suddenly and obviously means something along the lines of, “Where are your parents from?”, “What is your ethnic background?” or, “What language do you speak?”

To me, it reminds me of what and who I’m not, what I don’t speak, what I don’t know, and where I’m not from.

2. “I’m from [nearby-town-that-is-obviously-not-where-I’m-actually-from].”


When pressed, I usually used to answer something along the lines of, “My father is Egyptian, my mother is American.”

This answer, of course, is wrong on many levels (not least of which being that Egyptians in the US are often American citizens as in the case of my father, and that few Americans are indigenous to this country; my mother’s family emigrated from Italy).

Oftentimes, I simply want to run away from this question and just say “I’m Muslim!” For a little while, I tried to put my mixed heritage on the back-burner. 

3. “You don’t speak Arabic? How can you be Egyptian?”


Growing up, including my college experience, has been about better understanding identity, which includes heritage, history, ethnicity, race, and culture, and examining the environment and societal factors under which I was raised.

Dismantling the truths that I thought were unbreakable has been empowering but also endlessly frustrating, and it has really complicated my understanding of myself and my identity.

What does it mean to be Egyptian? What does it mean to be American? Most importantly to me, what does it mean to be Muslim? 

4. “This is my friend, Safaya, she’s from…”


I remember all of the events and programs that I used to go to at various mosques near where I lived; sometimes I would visit my friends from other towns and we’d meet up at mosques near their houses. Sometimes I felt like I knew even less about how to introduce myself than they did. I felt like I was always waiting for someone to ask me where I was from or what I was doing there, like I was constantly in disguise and the goal of the event was to figure me out in order to win a prize (*hums One of these things/is not like the others/one of these things/is not the same*).

I still feel lost sometimes at these events, even after Jummah prayer or during Taraweeh in Ramadan. I see that the Aunties and the Khaltus can all tell that I feel out of place, that I’m not “in the know.”

Instead of receiving their warm hugs, I’m awkwardly on the other end of a painful sideways-arm-movement-thing. Or worse…a handshake.

I’m a Muslim-American just like everyone else at the mosque, but I’m also, well…not.

5. “OMG, I totally knew  that you were white.”


I remember when someone told me this.

It was somehow a crushing blow at the time. I mean, I don’t know why I was so ashamed since I am half-white. But somehow I felt like being Egyptian, being not white, was meaningless. I was just white to this stranger I had just met. This stranger suddenly knew I was white. I didn’t even know who I was. Should I believe this stranger?

She seemed surer than I did.

6. “Wait, I thought you were [something else].”


I can’t count the number of hours that I’ve waited with (literally) bated breath, hoping and praying that someone will say “Of course you’re Egyptian! I could totally tell.” But I think what I’ve really always wanted to hear is, “You belong with us. You are who you are and that fits perfectly with who we are, too!” I don’t know who the “we” is, but I’m pretty sure whoever they are, they don’t exist.

Even if by some crazy chance they do, I’m done spending all my time waiting for them to show up. 

7. “Um, I’m Egyptian.”

“Er, I’m mixed.”

“Uh, I’m half Arab.”

“I’m bi-racial (right?).”


Every day for me is a challenge to remember that I am more than the sum of my parts – not just half Egyptian and half white, but fully Safaya.

Point blank, period.